Training, consultancy and resources to improve teaching and learning
You are here > Members' Resources > Online Learning Magazine > Issue 93: Silence
Top & Left Panes to Add
Add Modules from previous magazine issue
Header Pane - Getting Started
Magazine Back Issues
Trainiing Events
Teacher Premium Offer
Free Shop Delivery
Explore Resources
Books Membership

To read the learning magazine, download resources and to access site resources you'll need to join and login:

  • Standard Member: Free
    Monthly updates, magazine & limited resources
  • Teacher Premium Member: £24 per annum
    Monthly updates, magazine & all teacher resources
Find out more about each level >>
Books Training Events
Designing Effective Online Teaching & Training
Two 2hr Online Sessions
Please enquire for future dates
Further Info on Course

Free Online Zoom School
Next session:   26th Sept 10:45
Further Info on Course

Thinking Heads: 6 Sessions
for headteachers
One session each half term
Starts 12 Nov 20
  To be held Online or
Wandsworth, South London
depending on Covid-19
Further Info on Course

Thinking Deputies: 4 Sessions
for headteachers
One session each half term
Starts 11 Nov 20
  To be held Online or
Wandsworth, South London
depending on Covid-19
Further Info on Course

Availability On Key Dates:
All 20/21 Key Dates Available !

Professional Learning Available From Mike:
Online Training
Curriculum Design & Development
INSET & Non Closure Days
(New) Headteacher Executive Coaching
Thinking Heads Facilitation
Coaching Skills for Leaders
Video Coaching for Improved Teaching
Challenge 10 Toolkit - Quality Teaching
Programmes for MATs/TSAs/LAs
Books Teacher Premium Offer

Book Cover MI in PracticeMar 2020
This month's Teacher Premium Offer:

Multiple Intelligences in Practice £20.00
with free standard delivery in the UK

See expired members offers  

Shop Free Shop Delivery

Teacher Premium Members receive

  • Free UK Standard Delivery in the Thinking Classroom Book Shop
Magazine Issue 93: Silence
March 2018

This month: Thoughts about Silence

Article: Silence
New Resources
Mike's Books
Additional Resources

This Month's Article:


Silence An Article about the relationship between learning and silence.

This is a Free Sample Resource

Categories: Article, Professional Development, Educators

Tags: Silence Behaviour Contemplation Thinking Listening
Four monks decided to meditate silently without speaking for two weeks. By nightfall on the first day, their candle began to flicker and then it went out.

The first monk said, "Oh, no! The candle is out."

The second monk said, "Aren't we not suppose to talk?"

The third monk said, "Why must you two break the silence?"

The fourth monk laughed and said, "Ha! I'm the only one who didn't speak."

Now, if you were a hypothetical fifth monk, you might walk deep into the forest, sing at the top of your voice, and argue that because no-one heard you it didn't matter whether you were silent or not.

So, does silence matter when it comes to learning?

Party Talk

In my training, as some of you know, I run an activity called Edit Alley. Many of you go on to use it successfully in class. But it's a noisy task and not suited to everyone. Two lines face each other and discuss a topic. Then one line shuffles up so everyone has a new partner with whom they repeat the discussion. Everyone is talking at once but very few people see this as a problem. Sure, some might need to focus in a little more but, by and large, everyone is able to hear and be heard.

Children manage it too. They naturally move a bit closer to their partner and they manage to cut out sound that's not important. After 3 or 4 conversations with different partners they generally return to their seats quieter than when they left. They are all talked out. It's the kind of skill they'll need at adult social events - receptions, cocktail parties for example - the ability to tune in and tune out.

Positive Feedback Loops

Let's face it; some classes are quieter than others. One year your children might be passive, biddable and meek; the next, feisty, boisterous and noisy. The feisty ones are often more fun and creative - so long as some wide boundaries are securely in place. And classes like these can suffer from positive audio feedback loops: one child is excited and speaks a bit louder than everyone else. Everyone else raises their voices just a touch to compensate. Excited child does the same, in order to be heard. As does everyone else. Until it's noisy enough for you, guardian of ambiance, to intervene (maybe with a pre-agreed Soundscape - see this month's Thinking Tool).

Classes like this can be a real challenge to get silent. They are built to talk and have a lot to say. You wouldn't want them next to you in the cinema but you would on stage. So it's worth asking what value silence has in learning.

Why Be Silent?

Is silence about the teacher or the children? Is it what the teacher wants or what the pupils need? In what ways can silence help or hinder learning?

Ever get told off at school for talking to yourself as you struggle with a difficult task - when you are supposed to be silent? Ever do the same to a pupil of yours? In 1954, educator Edgar Dale proposed that the most effective way to learn something was to talk about it as you learned it - a kind of running self-commentary. Edgar did his research in the days when all you needed was a good rationale and a few folks for whom it kind of worked. But since then the idea of pole-bridging has confirmed his work. When we describe our thoughts and our actions - as they happen - we are 'bridging the poles' across thought, language and action and strengthening< the neural connections between them.

On the other hand, silence is like a blank page; daunting but full of creative potential. It's an opportunity ;to plan, think, prepare and take stock before speaking or acting. Some children need silence to concentrate. Others need to talk to concentrate.

Building a Classroom Soundscape

The question moves on from 'Should there be silence in class?' to 'What kind of soundscape best supports our learning?' Silence is just one building block of the audio environment in which diverse learners and their teachers work. In order to design soundscapes that support as many learners as possible, involve everyone in their creation. Use the ideas in this month's Thinking Tool to help. You can begin by seeking everyone's opinions on the following:

  1. What is the best kind of soundscape for this classroom so that everyone learns more?
  2. What is your individual soundscape preference?
  3. What are your rights and responsibilities regarding the sounds that happen in this classroom?

Use appropriate Thinking Classroom techniques to co-negotiate a whole class decision on what you're aiming for and then create visual representations of the soundscapes needed for different kinds of learning.

As you continue to monitor and evolve the soundscape have one question at the back of your mind:

What difference does silence make to effective teaching and learning in this room?

New Resources:

Soundscape Thinking

Soundscape Thinking A Thinking Skills Tool for defining, visualising and maintaining appropriate sound in class to support learning.

Categories: Thinking Tool, Visual Thinking, Skills-Based Learning, All Ages, PSHE

Tags: Environment Silence Noise
Free Standard Member Resource: Login or Join for Free to access this resource and others.

Soundscape Thinking PowerPoint

Soundscape Thinking PowerPoint A Thinking Tool Template in PowerPoint for easily creating soundscape visualisations for the classroom.

Categories: Visual Thinking, Thinking Tool, Skills-Based Learning, All Ages, PSHE

Tags: Environment Noise Silence
Teacher Premium Resource: Login or Upgrade to Teacher Premium to access this resource.

Silence Think Sheet

Silence Think Sheet A Think Sheet about silence.

Categories: Think Sheet, Enquiry Thinking, All Ages

Tags: Silence Noise
Teacher Premium Resource: Login or Upgrade to Teacher Premium to access this resource.


Mike's Books:

Books to help you think creatively about your classroom environment

Multiple Intelligences in Practice
by Mike Fleetham

Multiple Intelligences in Practice<br>by Mike Fleetham Book giving a clear introduction to multiple intelligences for all age groups. Addresses differentiation, inclusion, engagement and personalised learning through a single coherent philosophy. Gives you concrete examples and case studies of MI in school and shows how MI principles can help you improve the quality of teaching and learning.

Available in our shop

Find out more
Categories: Book & EBook, Multiple Intelligences, Any Subject, Educators

Tags: Multiple Intelligences CPD

Additional Resources:

Thinking Classroom Archive:

Skills Think Sheet - Imagination

Skills Think Sheet - Imagination A Think Sheet to kick start imagination. Redressing the balance after 2016's grammar Think Sheets.

Categories: Think Sheet, Thinking Skills, Other Subject, Infant, Junior

Tags: Imagination Creative Thinking
Teacher Premium Resource: Login or Upgrade to Teacher Premium to access this resource.



Silence In The Age Of Noise
by Erling Kagge

Silence In The Age Of Noise<br> by Erling Kagge Norwegian explorer Erling Kagge once spent fifty days walking solo across Antarctica, his radio broken. In this bestselling book he explores the power of silence and how we can get some of it into our daily lives.

Available from Amazon

Opens in a New Window
Categories: Suggested Books, Professional Development, Psychology

Tags: Silence Peace Calm Reflection


Classrooms That Are Kind On The Ears

Classrooms That Are Kind On The Ears "Classrooms generally have terrible soundscapes too. For a student sitting in the fourth row of a traditional classroom, speech intelligibility is just 50 percent, meaning that they only hear half of what their teacher says"
Thought-provoking TED Talk from Julian Treasure

Opens in a New Window
Categories: Websites, Professional Development

Tags: Soundscape Noise Classroom

Next month we think about Gender