Training, consultancy and resources to improve teaching and learning
You are here > Members' Resources > Online Learning Magazine > 2012 Magazine Issues > Issue 25: Self-Assessment
Books Membership

To read the learning magazine, download resources and to access site resources you'll need to join and login:

  • Standard Member: Free
    Monthly updates, magazine & limited resources
  • Teacher Premium Member: £24 per annum
    Monthly updates, magazine & all teacher resources
Find out more about each level >>
Books Training Events

Training Available From Mike:

Headteacher Executive Coaching; 

NQT/RQT Training Programmes for Local Authorities;

Cluster/Federation/Academy Chain Training Days

Books Teacher Premium Offer

Book Cover Thinking StoriesJun 2017
This month's Teacher Premium Offers:

Thinking Stories to Wake Up your Mind £20.99
with free standard delivery in the UK


Shop Free Shop Delivery

Teacher Premium Members receive

  • Free UK Standard Delivery in the Thinking Classroom Book Shop
Magazine Issue 25: SELF-ASSESSMENT
July 2012

This month ideas about and techniques for Professional Self-Assessment

Article: Professional Self-Assessment
New Resources
Teaching Tips
Wise Words

This Month's Article:

Professional Self-Assessment

img
Professional Self-Assessment An Article which sets out why we need to work in pairs or triads when we are developing our professional skills.
 
To doubt everything, or, to believe everything, are two equally convenient solutions; both dispense with the necessity of reflection.
Henri Poincare

We cannot observe external things without some degree of Thought; nor can we reflect upon our Thoughts, without being influenced…by the Things which we have observed.
William Whewell

What is self-assessment? What are its strengths and dangers? Why do it? How can it work?

This is a Free Sample Resource

Categories: Article, Professional Development, Educators, Any Subject

Tags: CPD Coaching
On a scale from 1 to 10, how would you rate yourself as an educator? That’s a real curved ball of an interview question isn’t it? And of course we all know that the right answer is 7.83. But what value is there in asking a question like this and is it ever possible to be sure of the answer?

Who Are You?
Have you ever met or worked with someone who rated themselves 10? Or maybe 0? As Poincare says, with self-perception like this, why bother reflecting? You’re either as good as you’ll get or beyond hope. And herein are the debilitating or arrogant dangers of self-perception. Your personal history and the shaping forces brought to bear by society can provide flawed ideas of who you really are. Any form of professional self-assessment should include a reality check. 

The Ghosh Test 
In 1982, Dr Baran Ghosh was convicted of theft. He appealed on the grounds that the judge had instructed the jury to ‘use their common sense’ when deciding if he had acted dishonestly. Ghosh argued that their decision should have been based solely on an assessment of whether he believed his actions to be dishonest. Although unsuccessful, his appeal lead to a modification of jury instruction on dishonesty. Firstly, a jury must decide if an ‘ordinary decent person’ would consider the accused’s actions to be dishonest. Then they must agree if, by those standards, the accused realised he was being dishonest. 

Professional self-assessment in school can use the same principle by asking, ‘Would an ordinary, decent teacher consider their colleague to be a 10 (or 0)?’ And, ‘does the colleague realise the implications of assessing themselves as 10 (or 0)?’ You need others with whom to discuss and validate your self-perceptions and you need clear criteria about which to talk.

Phone a Friend
These criteria are provided in professional standards, social norms, organisational principles and legal boundaries. Assess your day to day behaviours against these commonly accepted characteristics, and then ask a trusted (ordinary & decent) colleague to comment. That’s a valuable process for professional growth. Worthwhile self-assessment rests on discovering together what a characteristic looks like and then discussing if and how you are ‘looking like that’.

Process Not Endpoint
The original question is helpful because it kick-starts thinking. But its answer – even 7.83 – is meaningless unless you know what criteria a 7.83 meets. And, more importantly, what you have to do to become an 8.47. Professional self-assessment is a process of continually monitoring knowledge, skills and behaviours against increasing expectations. But why bother? Why not delegate the job to peers and bosses? Simple:  Research (Hattie, 2009) clearly shows that your learning is more effective when you are involved in its assessment than when the assessment is only ‘done to you’. And, after all, you know yourself best of all, don’t you….?


New Resources:

InfoMe Thinking

img
InfoMe Thinking A Thinking Skills Tool directed to professional development and providing a visual technique for representing personal skills and qualities.

Categories: Thinking Tool, Visual Thinking, Professional Development, Educators, PSHE

Tags: Infographic Visual Thinking Interview Preparation
Teacher Premium Resource: Login or Upgrade to Teacher Premium to access this resource.

InfoMe Thinking Powerpoint

img
InfoMe Thinking Powerpoint A Thinking Tool Template in Powerpoint, providing prompts and images for you to create an InfoMe graphic - an engaging visual representation of your skills, qualities, knowledge and aspiration.

Categories: Thinking Tool, Visual Thinking, Professional Development, Educators, PSHE

Tags: Infographic Visual Thinking Interview Preparation
Teacher Premium Resource: Login or Upgrade to Teacher Premium to access this resource.

Olympics Think Sheet

img
Olympics Think Sheet A Think Sheet designed for the London 2012 Olympics and useful for thinking about other sporting events.

Categories: Think Sheet, PE, Junior, Secondary, Thinking Skills

Tags: London 2012 Olympics
Teacher Premium Resource: Login or Upgrade to Teacher Premium to access this resource.


Teaching Tips:

Tips for Professional Self-Assessment

img
Tips for Professional Self-Assessment Teaching Tips for self-reflection. Three simple techniques to get you thinking about yourself and your qualities: 25 Wordle; 5 Why Self-Chat; Hi-Lo-LetGo.

Categories: Teaching Tips, Professional Development, Educators, Any Subject

Tags: Self Knowledge Personal Development Reflection
Teacher Premium Resource: Login or Upgrade to Teacher Premium to access this resource.

Wise Words:

"Follow effective action with quiet reflection. From the quiet reflection will come even more effective action"
Peter Drucker

Next month we think about fresh starts and new years.